Why does carmine always die

But believe me, friends, I don't say this because of maliciousness and I'm definitely not looking forward to Carmine's death - in order to satisfy some kind of perverse gratification.

Rather, Carmine's death could serve as a fitting turning point in the overall narrative. Allow me to explain. The death of the first Carmine brother, Anthony, was important because it showed that death in the Gears universe is persistent and unrelenting. Anthony's death was almost meaningless and, in a way, much more potent for the casualness with which it happened.

The death of the second Carmine brother, Benjamin, was important because of his innocence. Overeager in conversation and green on the field of battle, wondering when Benjamin might die was nerve-wracking. When his death finally came after falling out of a helicopter, subsequently his chest was melted by parasites, we were again shown the indifferent nature of the Gears universe. Once again, a Carmine brother died for nothing.

The reason that Clay Carmine must die is to show us that sometimes, occasionally, there is victory in death. I don't want Clay's death to be comical or arbitrary, I want it to mean something, to inspire hope.

Unlike Anthony and Benjamin, I want Clay to go out in a blaze of glory; a blaze that ensures that the Carmine name is burned deeply into the history of Sera, white-hot and unavoidable. I want Clay to redeem the Carmine name so that it stands for sacrifice - unflinching obedience to duty and victory at any cost. The point would be particularly fitting - as many equate the Carmine brothers with the average, anonymous COG soldier.

Save Carmine by Riley Little. Never in video game history have fans been able to determine the fate of a character - so we need to take the path less traveled and do something with this opportunity to save Clay Carmine. Anthony and Benjamin were both in their early twenties and act just like any kid thrown into a war would - but Clay is different.

We may have not see Gary after this. To a Deebee drop pod? No, we actually do get to see Gary again…. After JD and them get off the burning mining elevator, they must enter the Hive to save Marcus.

JD opens a door to see a room full of dead Juvies and one dead guy. To be honest, this room, scene and dialogue is unnecessary to the casual player, but it seems like the writers are telling us something. This dead guy is actually Gary. JD and them comment how this guy was a badass. It seems like he survived from the pod collision, got snatched by the Snacher, and with his Carmine DNA grit, managed to cut out of the pod Gears 5 Escape Style. He doesnt have his mask, maybe because he had to take it off during checkup with the headache.

He fought through hordes of these unknown enemies. Gary Carmine fought to the end, trying to save his village. This was his real family, people that looked up to him not like Anthony, Ben, or Clayton.

Sorry for the wait. Maybe Hoffman will dispatch a squad of Gears to bring him home User Info: srydecka. Hah yeah that would be funny. User Info: OnlyForOpinion. I sure hope for epic's sake that they don't kill the other two carmines. User Info: Kainscommando. All Carmines will die, its obvious after Carmine A. EPIC will keep killing off Carmines as a joke.

Poor Carmine C. Sadly, the Carmines are the red shirts of Gears. I don't mean that to be funny, but it is true. However, I didn't care much for Anthony, but Ben should've lived! User Info: xfpredator. Carmine is the shade of red used for the uniforms of the expendable officers on Star Trek away missions. The four brothers are destined to die. What if the fourth Carmine is actually Dom? Hilarity will ensue, lol. User Info: Kkashi.

Simple, its funny as hell. Messed up maybe, but funny.